The PCA’s Largest Presbytery: A Report from Evangel Presbytery
By Andy Jones
Urban Hope group

Dion Watts was facing the biggest exam of his life. After years of study and preparation, he was scheduled to be examined for ordination by Evangel Presbytery. But on the morning of Tuesday, November 10, he discovered that God had other plans. When his pregnant wife started having contractions, he faced a dilemma of whether to proceed to presbytery or remain with his wife. 

Evangel Presbytery meets four times per year. If he excused himself from the meeting, Dion would have to wait another three months to be examined and approved to accept a call. He contacted the committee chairman and, in consultation with his wife, decided to proceed to presbytery. The presbytery agreed to rearrange its docket so Dion could be examined as the first item of business and return home. 

Presbytery begins at 9:00 a.m., and a worship service is usually the first item of business. But on November 10, Watts preceded it and was examined by the Credentials Committee as the final part of his ordination exams. He passed and was approved for ordination. By 9:30 a.m., he was out the door and on his way home. 

The meeting of Evangel Presbytery required a longer commute than normal. The fall stated meeting was hosted by Rainbow Presbyterian Church in Gadsden, Alabama. The presbytery primarily consists of PCA congregations in the Birmingham metropolitan area, with a few outlying towns like Pell City and Gadsden being included. For most elders, including Watts, the meeting was at least an hour’s drive. 

Rainbow Presbyterian Church

Evangel is the largest presbytery in the PCA. More people are worshipping in its pews on Sundays than any other presbytery in the country. Other presbyteries may have more churches, but Evangel exceeds them all in total membership. This is due in part to having four large churches within its bounds: Briarwood, Covenant, Faith, and Oak Mountain. Those four churches alone have 10,000 members combined. By themselves, they would be the fourth-largest presbytery in the PCA. They are located within a four-mile radius of one another on the southern edge of the city. 

But there are 29 other congregations within Evangel’s bounds. Rainbow Presbyterian is the only PCA congregation in Etowah County, Alabama, on the northeast side of Birmingham. Though Birmingham is informally considered the hometown of the PCA, since it hosted the first General Assembly, Gadsden has had an outsized influence on the PCA. Jim Baird and Roy Taylor both served as pastors in the town. Randy Pope grew up in Gadsden, and he attributes Baird’s pastoral influence to the success he enjoyed planting Perimeter Church outside Atlanta. 

A large presbytery has large attendance. By my count, there were around 140 elders who made the drive, and elders say that when meetings are held in Birmingham, attendance is closer to 200 people. Given the size of the presbytery, it is clear that it leans heavily on its committees to facilitate much of the work. 

Though this presbytery meeting began with the anticipation of new life, it also was the occasion for the somber remembrance of a teaching elder who had just passed away. Mike Williams was the pastor at large for Evangel, a position where he provided pastoral care for the elders in the presbytery. As a result, he served as a confidant and counselor to many of Evangel’s pastors. The presbytery took time to acknowledge his contributions and also discuss plans to ensure his widow would be supported. 

Like most presbyteries, the meeting starts with a worship service and then proceeds with reports from its standing committees. But there is a special order of the day to hear a presentation from Kelly Kapic, professor of theological studies at Covenant College. His talk focuses on the Christian life as a response to God’s love for us, the subject of his most recent book. 

Covenant Seminary was also represented at the meeting by Teaching Elder James Dickson who gave an update on the progress of the seminary. The seminary has a renewed focus on pastor-minded students, which has led to one of its largest incoming classes in 15 years. 

In our national memory, Birmingham is often associated with the Civil Rights movement. Events like the 16th Street Baptist Church bombing shone a light on the racial hostility that existed in the city. A look around the room at the presbytery meeting, it is clear that the PCA congregations are still located in parts of town where the population is primarily white. However, there are encouraging trends in locations where the population is predominantly black. 

Urban Hope Community Church has put down roots in Fairfield, an economically impoverished city on the west side of Birmingham where the population is 90% black. At this meeting of presbytery, three candidates from Urban Hope took the first step in their journey toward becoming ordained ministers. They shared their testimonies and sense of call to the ministry before being approved as candidates. 

All three young men are participants in the Urban Hope Leadership Initiative, a nine‑month Christian leadership program for young black men. They come from different backgrounds — some have spent time in college, others in jail. But they have all been brought to faith in Christ and discipled through the local church. The hope is to see these men go to other towns like Fairfield and plant churches like Urban Hope. 

Watts has seen God transform his life through Urban Hope’s ministry. With his successful ordination exam, he has accepted a call to serve on the pastoral staff at Urban Hope and continue its ministry to young men in the area. 

Even better, Roman Watts was born at 11:58 a.m., less than three hours after his dad was examined for ordination by Evangel Presbytery. Thankfully, Dion made it home in time to get his wife to the hospital and witness the birth of his son. 

Scroll to Top