As many young Christians are trading their Protestant predisposition for the perceived substance of Roman Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy, Kevin DeYoung gives them a reason to reconsider. In his new book, “Church History for Everyone” (Crossway, 2026), DeYoung shows that Protestants value history and have their own claim to historicity. Moreover, many contemporary believers from non-denominational or “Big-Eva” contexts unknowingly suffer from lack of a historical understanding that would support a more robust theological framework and worship structure.
Protestantism is far from a-historical. Anyone seeking to find the “true church” out of the Protestant void will discover the aim of Protestantism is the preservation, not demolition, of the holy catholic church. As such, DeYoung’s work comes alongside other recent books, articles, and podcasts that follow Philip Schaff from almost two centuries ago in substantiating a “mere Protestantism.”
DeYoung’s work also helps believers of all generations, mindsets, and motivations to deepen and inform their expression of the gospel by studying past thinkers, leaders, and movements in church history. As an adjunct professor at Samford University, I am grateful for a new text suitable for students wanting to go beyond general overview history lectures to a detailed study of the early church up to the pre-Reformation period. I only assume when the promised Volume 2 is released, it will complete the picture DeYoung has deftly painted in Volume 1.
Any survey history work is susceptible to criticism based on the nature of the project. Summary requires selectivity. The volumes written by the early church fathers alone provide enough to study for a lifetime. Specifically, students of Augustine, myself included, may be disappointed to find DeYoung only allotted 10 pages to such a monumental figure.
Yet, historical summary is a needed and valid starting point. In my experience, even the most studious believers in Protestant circles and other traditions would struggle to place major events and people in church history on a timeline or understand how those connect to what came before and after. DeYoung’s work helps address that deficiency by providing a reasonably succinct initiation for contemporary believers.
At 350 pages, “Church History for Everyone” is not a quick read, but it is certainly more digestible than other seminary-level texts. DeYoung uses a biographical approach by centering each chapter on a particular figure, but don’t confuse this tome with children’s missionary “hero” books.
Each chapter also cleverly begins with a timeline on the bottom of the page, showing when the chapter’s content occurs within the span of dates and events covered in the book. This small inclusion helps the reader to keep his place in the story of Christianity. Particularly for younger generations accustomed to online and visual learning, this timeline will prove helpful. The discussion questions at the conclusion of each chapter also make this book a usable small group or adult Sunday school centerpiece.
Readers who know DeYoung’s strong Reformed confessional convictions and talent for a Reformed apologetic may initially need to recalibrate expectations. DeYoung says that he is specifically trying to show the positives of certain figures or ideas, even if they are part of a system where reform was much needed. As he aptly puts it, “We have to be realistic about our own history, but realism is not the same as cynicism. … History ‘warts and all’ should not mean history ‘warts and nothing else’” (4).
For instance, DeYoung helps us appreciate the Christian sincerity and discipline of early church desert monks and highlights the best aspects of medieval popes, even though he will later approvingly present early reformers’ polemics against the systemic and philosophical problems surrounding monasticism and the papacy. In order to help the reader understand his historiographical approach, DeYoung clearly explains the difference between giving those from the past a fair shake and presenting hagiography. DeYoung’s convictions come through, but the work is intended to teach from what can be positively affirmed with a broadly Christian perspective.
As to some of the specific areas he highlights, DeYoung begins by reminding readers of the continuity of life and relationships from the period of the biblical writers to the earliest church fathers such as Polycarp and Irenaeus. He keeps the boundary clear between subsequent church history and the apostolic era, unique for the establishment of the inspired, inerrant, and complete Word of God. Yet, he challenges and encourages believers today that we all are part of a continuous line of disciples who came to faith through the God-ordained witness of a previous generation.
As he explains dynamics of belief in the second- and third-century church, DeYoung introduces gnosticism and helpfully connects this with the need for the Rule of Faith. The idea that Scripture defines the Christian tradition and provides defense against any heretical movements is helpful for contemporary believers who may naively feel they are the first to have to discern theological errors.
DeYoung also analyzes the dynamics of persecution in several chapters. Those familiar with “Foxe’s Book of Martyrs” will know Perpetua and Felicitas. But DeYoung places that particular instance of brutality within the full-orbed reality of various Roman emperors who at different times restrained, permitted, or instigated forms of persecution.
DeYoung returns to this topic in a chapter on donatism, describing how the church of the past reacted to those who stood, or frequently fell, under pressure from peers or government. In our society where previously protected religious freedoms can feel fragile and believers are verbally attacked, DeYoung’s recounting of early persecution builds courage to stand and teaches grace toward those who might stumble.
DeYoung also links martyrs to monastics, stating “As the threat of governmental oppression decreased, the model of Christian heroism moved from the death-defying martyr to the world-denying monk”(66). Examining the life of Antony, he makes helpful correlations to contemporary admiration for structured eating regimens and fitness practices. He sees monastic discipline as a spiritual and life pursuit that can be similarly admired for its goal and rigor. At the same time, he critiques monasticism as a potentially legalistic movement focused on human performance. He also challenges the unbiblical gnostic dualism so often woven into monasticism.
However, this is a point where DeYoung’s generalized approach could be confusing for readers. He contrasts what he describes as “mainstream” and “extreme” approaches to Christianity. This seems like a false dichotomy between a more serious Christianity lived in isolation from “the world” and the “mainstream” faith of the church community expressed elbow-to-elbow with the lost. DeYoung undoubtedly does not intend to downplay the Reformation value for all of life under God, in the world or the New Testament framework of church community life as the centerpiece of the Christian existence, but this section could be read that way.
In addition to considering persecution and monasticism, DeYoung details the events leading to Constantine’s momentous decisions regarding the state and Christian faith. He raises questions of particular pertinence in our American moment and in light of current discussions about the role of church and state.
DeYoung helps us by presenting a series of questions concerning the end of official Christian persecution and later favored status for Christianity in the West:
- “Christianity and authority: Is the church better when Christians are in political power or out of power?
- Christ and culture: Is the world better when it takes courage to be a Christian or when it takes courage not to be a Christian.
- Church and state: Should the two institutions work together, work with one over the other, or be kept separate?
- The city of man and the city of God: Should we expect and work for some kind of Christendom on earth, or are we mainly pilgrims passing through this world to our heavenly home?” (100).
In his chapters about the Middle Ages and the late medieval period, DeYoung continues to broaden the typical scope for church or Christian histories by including state and military leaders. Charlemagne and Richard the Lionheart are presented as impactful contributors to Christian history, even if flawed like their pastoral and theological contemporaries may have been.
In particular, DeYoung counters a purely critical secular view of the Crusades with a fuller context of what motivated participants. Those Christians who favor a “counter-cultural” rather than “transformational” approach to government and military (to use Tim Keller’s categories) will likely view the impact of these military and governmental leaders differently than DeYoung, but he gives a clarifying perspective on this period rarely expressed or understood.
Finally, for those Reformation-minded Christians who might easily jump from Augustine to Luther, DeYoung reminds us of the figures of the 1200s and 1300s who both perpetuated the corruption of the church and resisted it. He reflects on monumental theological contributors like Aquinas as well as those, like Benedict, who attempted a type of reform within medieval Catholicism. By concluding with Jan Hus, DeYoung gives a decidedly Protestant closing and lays the bridgework for the subsequent dynamic period of the church in the West.
I hope many will follow the road DeYoung has paved in the important Christian practice of remembering, both for encouragement and correction, by engaging with this work. I am not aware of a more useful, digestible, sound summary of this period of church history than this. This volume truly represents church history for everyone.
Chris Peters serves as pastor of Cross Creek Church (PCA) in Hoover, Alabama.